Too Selfish

“It is impossible that a person should die for the love of a stranger.”

As soon as I read this quotation from chapter 22 of Wuthering Heights, I folded over the top corner of the page marking it in the moment as important. Most of the time when I look back at my highlights they don’t make sense or they no longer hold relevance as I’ve read further into the plot. This quotation, however, still stood out to me when I reread it. Although Nelly says it’s impossible that a person would die for a stranger, soldiers die for countries full of strangers everyday. Her words of disbelief to Catherine reflect the selfish and self-centered nature of the characters in this novel.

Firstly, Catherine makes the decision to marry Edgar Linton instead of Heathcliff. Instead of actually following her heart and marrying the man she actually loves, she selfishly marries the man with the most money. This decision causes all three characters unhappiness, as Catherine and Heathcliff cannot bear to be separate and Edgar Linton does not receive the love from his wife that a husband should.
Edgar Linton also acts selfishly by holding a grudge to Heathcliff and not allowing his daughter to converse or relate to his relatives at all. He is also so caught up in the memory of his wife that he refuses to celebrate his own daughter’s birthday. He also refuses to let Catherine see Linton even though she obviously loves him.
Heathcliff, on the other hand, encourages the union of Catherine and Linton. He does this out of greed and revenge, however; not because he truly cares about the pair’s feelings. Heathcliff also selfishly makes vengeful plans on the other characters because of his youth and lost love with Catherine.
I think throughout the rest of this novel, the idea of selfishness and self-made power will continue to be apparent, as Heathcliff’s plans successfully unravel and characters keep driving the plot by choosing their own self-interest over others.

Join the Conversation

  1. 20pswans's avatar
  2. cohanjr3's avatar

2 Comments

  1. I understand your point of view on Edgar’s selfishness in not allowing Heathcliff to see Cathy, but I think I have to disagree. Yes, it probably was selfish, but I can’t blame him. After everything that happened with his wife’s death and the pain that Heathcliff caused his family, he just wanted to protect his daughter from that same pain. Personally, if someone caused that much drama and struggle in my family, even if that person was a relative, I too would want to do everything I could to protect my family members.

    Like

  2. I agree that Wuthering Heights is full of self-centered people, yet I think that Nelly is possibly one of the worst of them all. As the narrator of the majority of the story of the family, she is able to possibly make some things seem worse than they actually are due to the unreliability in her narration. As someone who is close to the family, she can get caught up in the action, making someone look worse if they disagree with her, shown by the sudden changes in the characters, like how she flips her image of Heathcliff very quickly. Also, if she weren’t so selfish, she could have stopped Heathcliff’s plans to get revenge on the family before they even started. By holding information about Cathy going to see Linton just because of the safety of her job, she inevitably makes the entire situation worse, and on top of this, she continues to hide things from Mr. Linton, like the letters and the other meetings, until he is on his deathbed. If Mr. Linton has known about these things as soon as they happened, they could have been stopped, and he may not have died so soon of all the stress. Of all the characters, Nelly is the most selfish, as her selfishness allows Heathcliff’s plans to unfold.

    Also, I disagree with Edgar Linton’s selfishness. Though he is keeping Cathy away from going to Wuthering Heights, I believe that he is doing this to protect her. This is shown when she is imprisoned at the heights and forced to marry Linton, as well as after Edgar Linton dies and Cathy must live at the Heights, and she is filled with despair at how awful the place is (up until her and Hareton get together). Keeping Cathy from the Heights was a good thing, and once she does go, Heathcliff’s revenge is pushed into action.

    Like

Leave a comment

Leave a reply to cohanjr3 Cancel reply

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started